Daily The Patriot

New provinces, old problems

Link copied!

By Sardar Khan Niazi

The interior minister Mohsin Naqvi’s proposal to hold a referendum on the creation of new provinces has reopened a debate. There is little disagreement that Pakistan’s governance structure is under considerable strain. An expanding population, persistent regional inequalities, centralized decision-making and weak local governments have made the delivery of essential public services increasingly difficult. Large provinces also face serious administrative challenges in ensuring that remote districts receive adequate attention and resources. The first question that needs to be asked is what exactly is being proposed. Is the objective to create smaller provinces for administrative efficiency, to address longstanding regional grievances, or to redistribute political and economic power? These are related but distinct questions. Without clarity on the purpose, boundaries and institutional arrangements of the proposed provinces, a referendum risks reducing a complex national issue to a simplistic yes-or-no choice. The debate becomes particularly sensitive when it concerns the division of existing provinces. The Pakistan People’s Party has repeatedly opposed any move to divide Sindh, invoking the provincial assembly’s resolution on the matter. These differences cannot be resolved through political declarations or a referendum alone. The Constitution provides a specific procedure for altering provincial boundaries. Article 239(4) requires that a constitutional amendment affecting the limits of a province must be passed by the provincial assembly concerned by at least a two-thirds majority of its total membership. This safeguard is central to Pakistan’s federal structure. Any proposal for new provinces must respect it. A referendum may provide an additional indication of public opinion, but it cannot override constitutional requirements. Even where public consultation is desirable, the question remains who will formulate the referendum question, determine the proposed boundaries and establish the terms on which the public is expected to vote. Would citizens be asked simply whether they support more provinces, or would they be presented with specific proposals identifying territories, administrative structures and financial arrangements? Without these details, the exercise could generate more disagreement than consensus. There is also a more fundamental issue. If the existing governance system has failed, should the focus not first be on understanding why? Pakistan has repeatedly reorganized institutions, introduced constitutional amendments and announced administrative reforms without addressing the underlying weaknesses of public administration. Political interference, weak accountability, poor fiscal management and the limited autonomy of local governments continue to undermine service delivery. Creating additional provinces without correcting these weaknesses could simply reproduce the same problems on a smaller scale. The question of local government is particularly important. Pakistan’s citizens do not necessarily need another layer of political administration as much as they need functioning institutions closer to their communities. Local governments, where elected representatives can respond directly to neighborhood and district-level needs, remain an essential part of democratic governance. Their repeated weakening and premature dissolution have contributed to the concentration of power at provincial and federal levels. It is therefore difficult to discuss administrative decentralization meaningfully without addressing the failure to establish an effective local government system. The government should therefore begin by presenting a comprehensive policy paper outlining the objectives, financial implications, proposed administrative arrangements and constitutional requirements of creating new provinces. Parliament should lead an inclusive process involving provincial governments, political parties, constitutional experts, civil society and representatives of the regions concerned. A change in provincial boundaries may alter the administrative map of the country. It will not automatically change the quality of governance. Unless the underlying problems of accountability, representation, institutional weakness and political instability are addressed, a new provincial structure could end up inheriting the very failures it was supposed to resolve. The real test of a governance reset is not how many provinces Pakistan creates, but whether the state becomes more accountable and responsive to its citizens.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

New provinces, old problems

Link copied!

By Sardar Khan Niazi

The interior minister Mohsin Naqvi’s proposal to hold a referendum on the creation of new provinces has reopened a debate. There is little disagreement that Pakistan’s governance structure is under considerable strain. An expanding population, persistent regional inequalities, centralized decision-making and weak local governments have made the delivery of essential public services increasingly difficult. Large provinces also face serious administrative challenges in ensuring that remote districts receive adequate attention and resources. The first question that needs to be asked is what exactly is being proposed. Is the objective to create smaller provinces for administrative efficiency, to address longstanding regional grievances, or to redistribute political and economic power? These are related but distinct questions. Without clarity on the purpose, boundaries and institutional arrangements of the proposed provinces, a referendum risks reducing a complex national issue to a simplistic yes-or-no choice. The debate becomes particularly sensitive when it concerns the division of existing provinces. The Pakistan People’s Party has repeatedly opposed any move to divide Sindh, invoking the provincial assembly’s resolution on the matter. These differences cannot be resolved through political declarations or a referendum alone. The Constitution provides a specific procedure for altering provincial boundaries. Article 239(4) requires that a constitutional amendment affecting the limits of a province must be passed by the provincial assembly concerned by at least a two-thirds majority of its total membership. This safeguard is central to Pakistan’s federal structure. Any proposal for new provinces must respect it. A referendum may provide an additional indication of public opinion, but it cannot override constitutional requirements. Even where public consultation is desirable, the question remains who will formulate the referendum question, determine the proposed boundaries and establish the terms on which the public is expected to vote. Would citizens be asked simply whether they support more provinces, or would they be presented with specific proposals identifying territories, administrative structures and financial arrangements? Without these details, the exercise could generate more disagreement than consensus. There is also a more fundamental issue. If the existing governance system has failed, should the focus not first be on understanding why? Pakistan has repeatedly reorganized institutions, introduced constitutional amendments and announced administrative reforms without addressing the underlying weaknesses of public administration. Political interference, weak accountability, poor fiscal management and the limited autonomy of local governments continue to undermine service delivery. Creating additional provinces without correcting these weaknesses could simply reproduce the same problems on a smaller scale. The question of local government is particularly important. Pakistan’s citizens do not necessarily need another layer of political administration as much as they need functioning institutions closer to their communities. Local governments, where elected representatives can respond directly to neighborhood and district-level needs, remain an essential part of democratic governance. Their repeated weakening and premature dissolution have contributed to the concentration of power at provincial and federal levels. It is therefore difficult to discuss administrative decentralization meaningfully without addressing the failure to establish an effective local government system. The government should therefore begin by presenting a comprehensive policy paper outlining the objectives, financial implications, proposed administrative arrangements and constitutional requirements of creating new provinces. Parliament should lead an inclusive process involving provincial governments, political parties, constitutional experts, civil society and representatives of the regions concerned. A change in provincial boundaries may alter the administrative map of the country. It will not automatically change the quality of governance. Unless the underlying problems of accountability, representation, institutional weakness and political instability are addressed, a new provincial structure could end up inheriting the very failures it was supposed to resolve. The real test of a governance reset is not how many provinces Pakistan creates, but whether the state becomes more accountable and responsive to its citizens.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *